Best Judge

[MckeyMouse]

Who is the best out of the four?
jeanne beker
Yasmin Warsame
Mike Ruiz
Jay MAnuel

to me

jeanne beker is ummm........ im always on the fence with her critiques; they sound right, but at the same time don't. i have to say the worst judge out of the 4 at this moment, NOT because she basically sent Maryam home and bashed Meaghan numerous times, i just don't like her critiques.

Yasmin Warsame = fierce diva!! she knows what this industry wants and who looks like a model and who doesn't! because she is an actual model working.!!! she is so fierce and stunning and everything she says makes perfect sense.!! WERK!!

Mike Ruiz.. hes okay, but he slurs when he talks and sometimes i don't understand what he's talking about. Hes decent, but not that great. But he's a great photographer, unlike Nigel Barker, his photos in his website are actually great and fashion forward.

Jay Manuel, i think he's trying to hard to pick a bit of Tyra in his critiquing but i do think he is fair and not biased. But i feel like he judges the girls based on like one photo, instead of consistency at times. Sometimes i do feel like he is a great host and is really fair and knows who is modelesque and who has potential, but at times, i hate the fact that if one girl takes a good photo one week, he thinks that they're the bomb or something and will let them stay for a while.

so for me, the best judge is definitely Yasmin!!

[Chantal_Is_Love]

For me it's between Jeanne and Yasmin.

Mr. Jay tries to act like he's nothing like Tyra, when he's actually just a male version, almost.

[Jeff]

Mm.. Best Judge..

Its rather hard to say, because to be honest, All 4 of them have great critiques that all make sense. None of them are really biased at all.

Im just gonna say Yasmin because of the way she looks in panel

[someone110]

yasmin!!

[TopTop]

I like Mike the most...Yasmin has been a huge bitch this cycle, and Jeanne is just wrong in so many ways

[eruj]

I don't know who's the best, i haven't really been paying attention.

[Blom9168]

Mike because he's hot! No, but really because he gives the best criticism.

[Lacey-Vibe]

Tbh, I love all the judges But I guess I'd say Yasmin.

[spellboundboy]

Jay tries too hard to be like Tyra
Yasmin seems like she's losing it
Everytime I see the "Marc Jacobs and Louis Vuitton" documentary when Jeanne got kicked out from the Paris show I laugh at her
Mike Ruiz....is.......very.....fair....and.....honest..........and......his......critiques.....are....rock hard abs.....fair....honest.......Huh?

[phily693]

Yasmin is so at panel. She is someone to listen to and to respect a lot. Definitely one of my favourite judges from any NTM. I'm starting to see the motherly vibe from her recently which is nice.

Mr Jay is cool. He seems caring and he's a good host. I don't mind that he's like Tyra, the girl has presence and so does he in a different way to Tyra.

Jeanne is so eccentic (sp?) but that's what's so loveable about her. She seems very motherly to the girls especially when she cries when most girls are elimianted.

Mike is actually pretty good. He was a total shock. I thought he'd be a bore but he isn't.

[Tyler Neal]

Mike Ruiz

[omgwtfbbq]

Yasmin because she's just so glamorous. Idk Jay's just kind of there. He doesn't really make the show his own.

[luckyali]

Mike

In the past, I would say Jay but now, if all the things I have seen on TV are real, that must be Mike Ruiz

[oliver1990]

I don't get how could Yasmin be the best judge when she hardly speaks a word at the panel.

[MckeyMouse]

^ she makes the best expressions and tells it how it is.

yasmin "owwww i'll buy that dress"

CLOS UP

yasmin " never mind"

LOL. funny, divaesque, FIERCE, love this woman! and she got expensive taste.

[oliver1990]

^ she makes the best expressions and tells it how it is.

yasmin "owwww i'll buy that dress"

CLOS UP

yasmin " never mind"

LOL. funny, divaesque, FIERCE, love this woman! and she got expensive taste.

Her teach at the LG shoot for the girls was absolute NOTHING. It didn't make sense to me. I think all the girls could do better than her if they didn't have all the people around and the phones.

[Diversify]

By far Mike because he agrees with me the most and he loved Heather.

Jeanne and Yasmin have been wrong this cycle. Jeanne made fun of Heather but she did send Maryam home so I'm happy for that. Yasmin has been Maryam's fan since day one so I don't like her as a judge.

I have no opinion on Jay don't really like him as a judge. I think he's ok but I think he's a great host.

[SirLurk]

1. Yasmin
2. Mike/Jeanne
4. Jay - not that he's bad or anything, just the least helpful.