4/18 & 4/19 Top 7 Redux Performance & Results Discussion Thread

[Tainninho]

On a positive note, this is probably the strongest Final 6 since Season 8

With FOUR girls in it!

[ohreality]

The comeback of the girls!!!! My favorites live on! If Phillip wins he won't sell anyway!

[StefanSalvatore]

I cannot believe Colton was eliminated. Nor did he ended up in the bottom 3. I mean, I knew Elise and Hollie will be there, but the other person I predicted would be Skylar. S thank God she's still safe.

Well, it's a huge surprise that Colton got the boot. I thought his Bad Romance was terrific. And he's got so many screaming girls voting for him that he'd automatically go thru the next round.

Yay for Kris Allen's performance

[LadyLikeKiller]

sausage's party is over,boys!

[Anth]

Aw.

Now he has more time for me though.

[cocomoco]

Colton was sh!t as last night...Lady Gaga , srzly ?

Edit: OMG! , I never knew how much Elise be looking like Lady Gaga Irl ( when she ovi don't have all that makeup on)

[TSPKM]

So glad to see Colton go. And this is mean of me but I'm so happy to see the meltdown from the Colton fans. To say Colton doesnt fit in the category of the last 4 winners is just ridiculous. Phillip and Colton really arent that good and neither are versatile enough to actually make it in the music buisness. I'm so ready for someone new to win this show, hopefully it's Elise. She is amazing and so underrated by everyone. Wohoo Elise <3 making it one step further and double wohoo to getting rid of Colton and his arrogant attitude.

Next week, lets get rid of Josh or P2.

[Yorkie Dane]

Kris Allen killed it though, like woah.

His bulge was nicely filled too. Rofl.

[Betchis01]

This is so ridiculous. It never fails. Everytime the save is used, the very next week it's some "OMG HOLY CRAP SHOCKER NO NO NO HOW IS THIS HAPPENING".

I hate American Idol with a boiling passion of rage and hope it gets canceled. It's falling in ratings year by year. It's horrible.

And, to the people who think Jessica is going to get anywhere, she isn't. She'll be in the $5 bin soon after her obvious win. I'm getting the favoured brat out of my avatar. I'm not supporting her anymore.

To all crazed fans, it's one huge contradiction. If someone disses you guys' favorites, it's always "She's clearly the best! How can you not like her horrible, five pack a day smoker voice!!!!!", but if you guys diss mine, "Not everyone has to agree!!!!!!!!!!!!"

God.

I hate you Clayton Now!

[BeKazz]

To be honest i preferred Colton A LOT over Philip, but i am still happy that another guy got the boot LOL. Joshua and Philip need to sashay away next, to finally have an all-girl top 4. Because that would be something that'd make the show a tad bit more bearable for me to actually watch. Right now i only read the recaps on homorazzi were they post all the videos because the show is far too dragged out. :/
Go Godessica and Elsus Im beginning to like Skylar more and more, i just wish she'd do something else than Country ONCE

[Nade]

So glad Colton's out!

But sorry to his fans.

[Katantoon]

Colton was sh!t as last night...Lady Gaga , srzly ?

Edit: OMG! , I never knew how much Elise be looking like Lady Gaga Irl ( when she ovi don't have all that makeup on)

I thought it was gaga at first :D

and lol the meltdowns

[Weekendlover17]

^ that IS Lady Gaga

OMG I'm soooo glad Elise is still in!!!!!

[cocomoco]

I thought it was gaga at first :D

and lol the meltdowns

That is Gaga. This is Elise

[Ethan]

Wth...

Colton was amazing. I felt it every single time he sang with the piano. He is such a great musician and I have so much faith that he will continue to do great things. I'm really shocked because I had no idea what bad night could do this to someone with such a big fan base as Colton. Ugh, I'll really miss seeing him each week. I feel like he could have done so much more and I was gunning for him to be in the finale...

I'm still dazed as heck. RnR, I'll be here for you!

ETA: I really hate seeing all these negative Colton comments here. He definitely did not deserve to leave. He is the most marketable contestant here and I really, really loved seeing Colton perform. I get this whole anger over the WGWG thing and them always winning but like some others said here before me Colton NEVER played the guitar on the show. Just because he's white and attractive it doesn't instantly make him a WGWG. He has a totally different style IMO and I'm going to really miss him. Ugh...

[gleek]

LMFAO is freaking bad onstage! Kinda ok Colton left. I knew he won't win. Maybe many people did not like his outfit on the Bad Romance cover. Jk

[Betchis01]

My reaction when colton is eliminated


My reaction when elise was safe


My reaction when holly is safe.


My reaction when clayton says that he hates jessica

My reaction when clayton hates jessica

[HaleyReinhart]

AHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA OH GOD HAAHHAAHHHAHAHAAHHA

Okay. I had to get this big laugh out of my chest.
Thank god he was eliminated 7th and not 3rd like James last season.

Hollie really disappoints me, last season was so much better for her. Ugh, and I would've felt really bad if she was eliminated instead of Colton, she had so much potential and she never really got to show it.
Oh Hollie.