Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Kelly Clarkson Won't Let Idols Perform Her Songs

  1. #1

    Kelly Clarkson Won't Let Idols Perform Her Songs

    January 18, 2006 -- 'AMERICAN Idol" producers have some words for first- season winner Kelly Clarkson: Don't forget your roots.

    The pop singing sensation has apparently failed to sign off on allowing "Idol" to use her songs during its fifth season, which began last night.

    Executive producer Nigel Lythgoe says he believes it's all a paperwork misunderstanding and said that he has calls into Clarkson's business manager.

    But Simon Cowell warned that if Clarkson was trying to disassociate herself from the monster TV talent show that made her famous it would be career suicide.

    "That [would be] a big mistake," he told a group of reporters yesterday.

    "When they walk away from the show and try to forget . . . it's not the show itself [that is affected], it's the people who bothered to vote week after week.

    "They're the people who put her where she is today. And I think that by ignoring the show, you're ignoring the audience that put you there."

    A spokesman for Clarkson could not be immediately reached for comment yesterday.

    Despite Cowell's sharp words, the judge admitted that Clarkson's success is crucial to the show.

    "Kelly Clarkson's been so important to this competition," Cowell said. "The fact that her second album has done better than her first album, it makes people want to win this show. ''
    http://www.nypost.com/entertainment/60658.htm

  2. #2
    Hmmm... I say smart move on behalf of Kelly's parts. Yes, you may have roots in a show, but have the time, people who sing your song in the show aren't good...

  3. #3
    I don't understand why people sing ANY song that a winner or a really good former contestant has ever sang. Ninety-five percent of the time they don't measure up anyway.
    Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

  4. #4
    Kelly Clarkson has allowed them to use her song.

  5. #5
    If I directed AI, I wouldn't want to use Kelly's songs anyways. This is a pop competition, and Kelly's more rock now and doesn't really fit in.
    Paradise Hotel: Beds, Beaches, and Beyond...
    Challenge 1 results are up! http://realitytvgames.net/showthread.php?t=1922&page=7

  6. #6
    I agree with everyone.

    Kelly shouldn't have to let them use her songs. And if they did, there is no way it would be even half as good. And Antm is right, her style isn't what they are "looking for" anyway.
    Whoever said nothing's impossible, obviously never tried nailing jello to a tree.

  7. #7
    I feel Kelly should allow them to sing her first album song's, since American Idol had some input, and affiliation with the production of that album. The second album though, was all Kelly, and her own new direction on thing's. So if she want's to finally break away, from just being "That American Idol Girl" that's the way to do it. Especially with this album, she's done half the job, she just need's to stand her ground in this endeavor. I support Kelly 100%!

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by Rashad
    I feel Kelly should allow them to sing her first album song's, since American Idol had some input, and affiliation with the production of that album. The second album though, was all Kelly, and her own new direction on thing's. So if she want's to finally break away, from just being "That American Idol Girl" that's the way to do it. Especially with this album, she's done half the job, she just need's to stand her ground in this endeavor. I support Kelly 100%!
    *holds a big "yeah that" sign*

    It would be like her signing up for The Surreal Life right after winning AI. She's a smart cookie.

  9. #9
    Kelly won two Grammys last night for Pop Vocal Album and Female Pop Vocal Performance. She definitely deserved it!

  10. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Model Behavior
    Kelly won two Grammys last night for Pop Vocal Album and Female Pop Vocal Performance. She definitely deserved it!
    I know! She was so cute when she won, crying and all.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •